omg so glad I stumbled upon this forum!! totally takes me back. I literally used to spend hours on forums back in the 2000s lol. btw Charmed is my absolute fave show ever! love meeting people who get it.
Prue is my favorite.
Charmed is my favorite
-
Anthonyzier
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Thu Sep 03, 2026 1:35 pm
Re: Charmed is my favorite
Oh you hit the jackpot with this thread, Charmed is literally my ultimate comfort show.
Tbf those first 3 seasons with Shannen Doherty are just in a league of their own. That late 90s vibe was so much darker and grounded, and the chemistry between the original sisters felt way more real imo.But I actually respect Rose McGowan a lot. The writing got way too campy later on with all the mermaids and fairy tale stuff, but Rose brought a cool energy that saved the show from cancellation. Plus knowing how much Shannen and Rose actually supported each other in real life against all the backstage drama makes me appreciate Paige a lot more. Prue is still the GOAT though no question about it!!
Tbf those first 3 seasons with Shannen Doherty are just in a league of their own. That late 90s vibe was so much darker and grounded, and the chemistry between the original sisters felt way more real imo.But I actually respect Rose McGowan a lot. The writing got way too campy later on with all the mermaids and fairy tale stuff, but Rose brought a cool energy that saved the show from cancellation. Plus knowing how much Shannen and Rose actually supported each other in real life against all the backstage drama makes me appreciate Paige a lot more. Prue is still the GOAT though no question about it!!
Re: Charmed is my favorite
Let's be clear for a change... and yes, pun absolutely intended. 
There is a reason Shannen Doherty always got written off her shows. She lasted four seasons on Beverly Hills, 90210 and exactly three seasons on Charmed. Alyssa Milano was the real star who kept the show professional, stable, and running for eight full seasons. Phoebe had the best character development, the best outfits, and actually stayed loyal to the fans until the very end!
There is a reason Shannen Doherty always got written off her shows. She lasted four seasons on Beverly Hills, 90210 and exactly three seasons on Charmed. Alyssa Milano was the real star who kept the show professional, stable, and running for eight full seasons. Phoebe had the best character development, the best outfits, and actually stayed loyal to the fans until the very end!